Home| Subscription| RSS| Contact| Newsletter| Search| Wein forum German
 
Advertisement:
Username:   Password:   Permanent login 
Free registration | I lost my password | Subscription | Help
Our advice for you: Register free and without obligation. Your data will never be passed on to others. Promised!

Web-access to wine forum (not logged in)

Date: 2005-11-20 04:22:29
From: Raymond

Subject: Need Info About This Wine


Hi guys
Thanks for your time and replies to "German Classification". I guess
I've learnt enough of the very basic to buy what I like to drink.
I found this kabinett [Gimmeldinger Meerspinne halb-trocken 2004]
www.thewinecompany.com.sg/ in our local store. For US$17, the
price seems reasonable. Much lower than those I have been buying.
However, I need some tasting notes and opinions. It doesn't seem to
be from a top producer but could it be one of those cheap and
not-too-bad Rieslings?
My references:
- Donnhoff Kabinett Fruity 2003 (US$31) ­ best I’ve tasted.
- Bishop Mosel off-dry in a translucent Bordeaux bottle (US$11),
perhaps the dullest so far for my standard.
If I’ve learnt something about German Riesling, I have learnt that a
good wine is not about style (dry or sweet) but good quality and
balance ­ correct me if I am wrong. Depending on mood and type of
food, I drink both dry and fruity. I strongly feel that if Germany
went completely for the dry style it would be the greatest mistake.
I'd sampled an Aussie fruity Riesling lately, it couldn't even come
close to the Donnhoff. The upfront apricot, peach and slate are
missing and the finish was short. On the other hand, most of their
very dry ones are too tart and powerful for me.
Ray


This message was created using the Web-based forum :
www.wein-plus.com/forum/


More infos: www.wein-plus.com
Unsubscribe: www.wein-plus.com/abmelden.htm
Subscribe the free wein-plus.com newsletter!
Your e-mail adress:
This newsletter is free. Your e-mail adress
will not be passed on to others!

Wein-Plus is an independent medium. We place great store by the separation of editorial
content and advertising. Naturally, we do not trade with wine, and are not financially
connected, directly or indirectly, with any wine merchants or producers.
Please also note our additional legal notes and disclaimers in the Imprint.
We respect your right to privacy.  See our statement of privacy.
© Copyright 1998 - 2007 Wein-Plus, Utz Graafmann, Erlangen.
All rights reserved, reproduction only with written permission by Wein-Plus or Utz Graafmann.