Home| Subscription| RSS| Contact| Newsletter| Search| Wein forum German
 
Advertisement:
Username:   Password:   Permanent login 
Free registration | I lost my password | Subscription | Help
Our advice for you: Register free and without obligation. Your data will never be passed on to others. Promised!

Web-access to wine forum (not logged in)

Date: 2005-11-19 21:57:00
From: Peter.Gebler@t-online.de

Subject: Re: GERMAN CLASSIFICATION - PUZZLE!!

Dear Tony, Raymond, and the few that have tuck with this topic.

I attended a function this evening at Schloss Vollrads in the the Rheingau, and was able to speak to the manager there, Dr. Rowald Hepp, as well as several professors from the College at Geisenheim, and the head of the German Wine Institute (sounds like name-dropping, it really was quite an evening).

If you can believe it, even this illustrious group could not give me a definitive answer.

The Rheingau is currently the only region in which the regional First Growth regulations have been accepted into law. All the other regions have merely VDP regulations, and thus each region can decide whether the regional rules on First Growths preculde chaptalising or not. As far as I could establish, the Rheingau does not allow chaptalising in FGs, but Mosel and Rheinhessen most likely do.

Another anomaly came out in the discussion - a producer may only produce on First Growth wine per vintage. So, if for instance a winery decides to pick some grapes from their classified vineyard when the grapes have Spätlese must weight levels, and declare this as their First Growth for the vintage, then any grapes they leave hanging, to later produce an Auslese level or even a botrytis dessert wine, may not be labelled as a Frist Growth.

I agree that perhaps fewer laws and more market forces may be the answer. Perhaps I should switch to a job with fewer complications than German wine.

Kind regards from the Mittelrhein region
Peter

<
More infos: www.wein-plus.com
Unsubscribe: www.wein-plus.com/abmelden.htm
Subscribe the free wein-plus.com newsletter!
Your e-mail adress:
This newsletter is free. Your e-mail adress
will not be passed on to others!

Wein-Plus is an independent medium. We place great store by the separation of editorial
content and advertising. Naturally, we do not trade with wine, and are not financially
connected, directly or indirectly, with any wine merchants or producers.
Please also note our additional legal notes and disclaimers in the Imprint.
We respect your right to privacy.  See our statement of privacy.
© Copyright 1998 - 2007 Wein-Plus, Utz Graafmann, Erlangen.
All rights reserved, reproduction only with written permission by Wein-Plus or Utz Graafmann.