Home| Subscription| RSS| Contact| Newsletter| Search| Wein forum German
 
Advertisement:
Username:   Password:   Permanent login 
Free registration | I lost my password | Subscription | Help
Our advice for you: Register free and without obligation. Your data will never be passed on to others. Promised!

Web-access to wine forum (not logged in)

Date: 2005-04-02 18:31:19
From: BLVDDAD@aol.com

Subject: Re: Hi, Fellow wine lovers. I've a...


Dear David,

Thank you. I much enjoyed reading your note. There are one or two things
that could be brought up to date, and you might want to read further upon:

The word 'Kabinett' is defined in the 1971 Wine Law. It's a made-up word
that derives from another term formerly used, 'Cabinett', but which has an
entirely different meaning. (It means special wines designed for cellaring.)
The 1971 Wine Law defines a Kabinett very exactly; one does not have to 'know
what this means'. However, Hugh Johnson liked a certain light, foamy, flowery
style of Kabinett that showed all the qualities of the vineyard as he put it
'in miniature'; many lovers of German wine like this style, which cannot be
made easily or at all in very hot years like 2003. 2002 and 2001 produced
more wines of this style.

I am not aware of any wine laws in Germany passed in 1964.

It is not illegal to add sugar to wines in Germany, but it is illegal to
add sugar to a certain type of quality wines called 'Qualitätswein mit
Prädikat'. The wines that MAY contain sugar are those you refer to as 'QbA', or
'Qualitätswein bestimmtes Anbaugebiete', or 'quality wines from a designated
region'.

The vineyard in Worms to which you refer is actually called the "Wormser
Liebfrauenstift-Kirchenstuck". This may be the origin for the name
'Liebfraumilch', as is generally assumed.

The Riesling that is now sold coming from California is identical with the
German 'Weißer Riesling', by United States Law.

Müller-Thurgau is now recognized as being a Riesing x Riesling cross.

Best, John Trombley

In a message dated 4/2/2005 1:25:05 A.M. Eastern Standard Time,
boscastle@T-Online.de writes:


Well Raymond, you seem to have lots of opinions to consider! For what
it's worth I agree the lieblich style will never disappear

Perhaps you should remember one or two basic facts about the Riesling
grape which others haven't touched on yet. First of all you have to
remember that this is probably the most difficult country as far as
latitude and weather is concerned to produce wine. (Hence although
10% of wine production is red (and most of it here in Baden and
Württemberg) little of it is very good which is why there is hardly
any exported). The Riesling is a hardy vine well suited to this
climate - in fact when grown elsewhere it is either another grape
(like the Californian so-called Riesling or Italian Riesling which is
Wechselriesling) or it doesn't produce wines with the delicacy and
subtleness of taste like a good German Riesling. Riesling can be
crisp and dry and if you know what you're looking for - and often is.
Some labels have the word Trocken (Dry). My advice is look for a
'Kabinett' wine which is strictly speaking a non-recognized older
description used before the 1964 wine law but it's traditional and
everyone knows what it means. Remember too there is a difference
between a QbA wine and a QmP; the latter being from a more specific
area or vineyard - (not that it always means much since
half a dozen growers can work in one vineyard. Some of the
Piesporter vineyards are good examples; so to is Wehler Sonnenuhr).
Qualitätswein mit Prädikat can have 5 additional grades of which the
most common is Spätlese (late harvest). We are typical here in
Baden-Württemberg in that the harvest usually begins aroound
early/mid-October. Most of the QbA and QmP wines will be pressed
from this main gathering. Grapes still left on the vine - (given
enough sunshine) - begin to age and gradually shrivel in size which
means the sugar content gets more concentrated - hence the increasing
sweetness of Spätlese and Auslese. If he is lucky the vintner will be
able to make Beerenauslese (grapes still on the vine which are
beginning to rot) or Trockenbeerenaulese when the remaining grapes
are smaller still and resemble sultanas. If any are selected and
picked with frost still on them you have Eiswein. These later
gradings produce true dessert wines.

So the Riesling can and does product a variety of wines and a good
one has
that lovely delicate balance between fruitiness and crispness. It's
a
balance between acidity and sweetness.

Unfortunately most wine in the UK is sold in supermarkets and
although it is possible to find reasonable and good value wines don't
forget the
supermarkets have helped to ruin the availability of good wines.
Supermarkets need (1) huge quantities of wine (2) at a minimum price
for
maximum profit and (3) it must be consistent in taste ie. one batch
must
taste much like another. Result is blending and since adding sugar
is
illegal producers use grape juice or Sussreserve. As this alters
the
flavour markedly (and does not have to even come from the same
vineyard or
village) it is possible to achieve the same kind of bland uniform
taste.
It's not helped by the supermarket and high street drinks shops
using
generic names like Mosel Blümchen, Niersteiner Gutes Domtal, Black
Label
and, of course, Liebfraumilch (which by the way means nothing to a
German.
There is a Liebfraumilch vineyard (in Worms) but it is illegal to use
the
name in the way that British and Americans do.

Last thought - because Riesling grapes have a relatively small yield
various let us remember hybrids have been produced using the Riesling
as a starting point. So we have Müller-Thurgau (cross between
Riesling and Silvaner) which ripens earlier and has a greater yield.
Can be quite pleasant but my tip for a different German experience is
try Kerner. We've drunk many a bottle of it and it tends to have a
fairly consistent dry taste. One final tip - don't make the mistake
most British and Americans make of thinking you MUST always have wine
with food. German people often drink wine by itself - (we usually do
and I'm English!) What better than a little cheese and a good QmP
Riesling on a warm summer evening together with friends? David
Williams.


This message was created using the Web-based forum :
www.wein-plus.com/forum/





More infos: www.wein-plus.com
Unsubscribe: www.wein-plus.com/abmelden.htm
Subscribe the free wein-plus.com newsletter!
Your e-mail adress:
This newsletter is free. Your e-mail adress
will not be passed on to others!

Wein-Plus is an independent medium. We place great store by the separation of editorial
content and advertising. Naturally, we do not trade with wine, and are not financially
connected, directly or indirectly, with any wine merchants or producers.
Please also note our additional legal notes and disclaimers in the Imprint.
We respect your right to privacy.  See our statement of privacy.
© Copyright 1998 - 2007 Wein-Plus, Utz Graafmann, Erlangen.
All rights reserved, reproduction only with written permission by Wein-Plus or Utz Graafmann.